Paulomi Tripathi, Indian diplomat at Permanent Mission of India to UN replying to Pakistan at UNGA with the real picture of Pak-sponsored terrorism in J&K, during the 72nd United Nations General Assembly in New York, Sept. 25. (Press Trust of India)
India slammed Pakistan for using a “fake picture” in the UN General Assembly, Sept. 25, to push a “completely false narrative,” a day after its Permanent Representative presented an image of a girl from Gaza as a victim of pellet guns in Kashmir. UN General Assembly President Miroslav Lajcak has said that he will look into how to deal with the use of erroneous pictures, days after Pakistan’s Permanent Representative to the UN used a photo to portray an injured Gaza girl as a Kashmiri pellet gun victim.
Exercising her right to reply hours after External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj blasted Pakistan for its support to terrorism, Pakistan’s Permanent Representative to the UN Maleeha Lodhi, in a major goof-up, held up a photograph of a woman whose face was peppered with alleged pellet gun wounds.
“This is the face of Indian democracy,” Lodhi said of the picture which had no connection with Kashmir.
The picture of 17-year-old Rawya abu Joma’a of Gaza, an alleged victim of an Israeli attack was actually taken by award-winning American photo journalist Heidi Levine in July 2014.
“The Permanent Representative of Pakistan misled this Assembly by displaying this picture to spread falsehood about India. A fake picture to push a completely false narrative,” said Paulomi Tripathi, a junior Indian diplomat at the Permanent Mission of India to the United Nations.
Tripathi took the floor of the General Assembly to exercise India’s right to reply to the blistering attack by Lodhi.
“The Permanent Representative of Pakistan, in her statement, yet again sought to divert attention from Pakistan’s role as the hub of global terrorism. She did so by callously holding up a picture of an injured girl,” Tripathi said.
“The picture was taken on July 22, 2014 by an American photographer, Heidi Levine. This photograph was published by New York Times on March 24, 2015 under the caption ‘Conflict, Courage and Healing in Gaza,’” she said.
“In view of this cynical and misleading attempt by Pakistan, we are constrained to show this Assembly, a photograph that reflects the real picture of pain inflicted by the nefarious designs of Pakistan on India,” she said showing a picture of Lieutenant Umar Fayaz.
22-year Umar, who was posted with 2 Rajputana Rifle, was picked up from his house at Harmein in Kulgam in May. The body of the young officer was later found about two miles from his house.
“This is a real and not a fake picture of Lt Umar Fayaz.
A young officer from the Indian State of Jammu and Kashmir.
Umar Fayaz was kidnapped at a wedding celebration. He was brutally tortured and killed by Pakistan-supported terrorists in May 2017,” Tripathi said showing the picture.
“This is a true picture. It portrays a harsh and tragic reality. A picture of terrorism emanating from across our borders that the people of India, especially in the state of Jammu and Kashmir have to struggle with, every day.
“This is the reality which the Permanent Representative of Pakistan sought to obfuscate. The true face of Pakistan is not hidden from anyone,” Tripathi said as she displayed the two pictures again to the international community.
Pakistan, meanwhile, continued with its fake narrative against India.
Speaking on behalf of Pakistan, Tipu Usman, counselor at Permanent Mission of Pakistan to the UN, claimed, “Kashmiris want freedom form brutal Indian occupation.”
They will continue to rise again and again and again, he said.
“Kashmiris will take bullet after bullet; pellet after pellet but will never give up. The real issue is of human life, of human eyes, of children and infants blinded forever,” he said.
Usman alleged that India’s diversionary tactics will not change the situation on ground.
“It is the situation on ground that India has to answer for. It is the call for legality, morality and conscience that it has to answer for,” he said.
When asked if he would like to set some sort of factual baseline when people make use of a wrong photograph, UNGA President Miroslav Lajcak said, “I will certainly think about it.”
At the same time, he said it was a matter of diplomacy.
“It is not for me to answer. It’s for the delegations that are involved. I want to use but not misuse my position as President of the General Assembly,” he said.